Friday, April 8, 2016

4-7-16 Breast Cancer discussion

4-7-16
We heard Emily review a number of stressful life occurrences in the 2 years prior to her diagnosis.  She relates the life stress as contributing to the breast cancer.  Have you thought about immune status and a disease/condition like breast cancer?  How will biologic therapies affect this?

In the prior discussion, data says that mammograms will miss about 15% of new tumor growths. Emily said she had yearly mammograms for the 6 years prior to diagnosis. Yet this tumor was missed.  Ideal screening tests would have the ability to have no false positives and no false negatives.  (No one is told she has it when she does not and No one is told all is good when there is a tumor present). Do you understand why she was likely missed?

What other thoughts and comments do you have?    Did the speaker help your understanding of treatment?

12 comments:

  1. I think Emily did an excellent job presenting her experience with breast cancer to the class. I found it very interesting how the stress in her life contributed to a decrease in her immune system and the eventual diagnosis of breast cancer. I am also a person who likes to be constantly active and over-committing myself, so I understand that mentality and how it's so easy to ignore your own health when there's chaos all around you. Emily did a really good job at educating me on places where I can be a better pharmacist for patients going through cancer treatment, and I'm very grateful for her presentation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I found Emily to be extremely well-prepared to talk about her experience. She did a great job in detailing the events up to the point of diagnosis, which really gives you an ability to empathize with her situation. It was interesting to get the perspective of a pharmacist as a patient.

    Stress an immune function as an aspect of cancer is a really interesting thing to consider. I know that I tend to be a person that can over-commit (as I think maybe a lot of us in the program do), and this was really a reminder that there are consequences to over-doing it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Emily thinks that extreme stress caused immune compromise in her case. On the TODAY show 4/13/16 - there was a discussion about cancer being an immune disease which is why immune therapies seem to be so good -- and they cited Pres Jimmy Carter and his pancreatic cancer as an example. Is it s mutation in the DNA/RNA or an immune imbalance Cytotoxic therapy is not as expensive as the immune/biologic therapies. What do you think??

    ReplyDelete
  4. After this presentation, I feel more comfortable counseling patients with cancer. I had never thought about how essential hydration was after treatment or which foods not to eat after chemotherapy.Emily was very organized. The idea of stress being a risk factor for breast cancer was not something I had previously considered. In response to the TODAY show, I think it is a combination of the two. There is a mutation in the DNA/RNA but the immune system is not working correctly to identify that problem.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think it was extremely beneficial to have Emily come in and share a patient's perspective on her treatment. I definitely agree that there is a strong possibility on the correlation of stress and her developing cancer. If I just think of myself, I am always way more likely to get sick when I am stressed. There has been many times that I have come down with a cold right after clusters. During times of stress, especially when people are not sleeping well or eating well, the immune system is not as functional. In these cases, the immune system may not be able to identify dysfunctional and potentially cancerous cells before a tumor is formed.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I had never previously considered stress being a risk factor for cancer, but after hearing Emily's story I can see how stress may have contributed to the progression of her breast cancer. Taking clusters, I think we all know how much stress can suppress our immune systems, but it is interesting that stress may be a contributing factor for cancer. I am curious to see if there are any studies in the future on this.

    In class we discussed how self breast exams can be inconsistent and don't detect cancer until the later stages, but I did not realize that mammograms can miss up to 15% of tumors. It makes me believe that monthly self breast exams are important, especially if yearly mammograms can be missing such a significant percentage of tumors.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I do understand why her mammogram missed her tumor, and I think this is good to let our patient's know to check their breasts regularly (especially since the guidelines didn't really say it's beneficial this last revision). I think it's important to for women to know, like you stated, that a mammogram screening isn't a one size fits all, and that actually you have to be the ideal candidate. My question is there a difference in the races due to more prevalence of actual breast cancer, or is it because of differences in mammogram screenings (those who go get one, as well as skin density differences).

    I really enjoyed our guest speakers story. I could see myself a lot in her personality wise and I felt that she did a good job of addressing us as pharmacy students as well as people. It made me realize that when you go out and get a job, it's not always about the work, but also about the people you meet. She continually said how much she relied on them and how they helped her with no questions asked. And with her situation, I think those people are reason she is still going forward and getting through all of her hurdles. It is very inspiring.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Before hearing Emily's story I have never really considered stress as a contributing factor to breast cancer or other cancers. After hearing her story and all of her stressful life events I can see how stress could affect her immune system and allow cancer to grow. It's kind of shocking to me that she had routine mammograms for the past 6 years before she was diagnosed. I never knew that women with dense breast tissue are at higher risk of not detecting cancer with mammograms.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I really enjoyed the speakers candid responses and openness of her story. I had no idea stress could play into it so much. I also was surprised at the inaccuracy of mammograms.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I really enjoyed the speakers candid responses and openness of her story. I had no idea stress could play into it so much. I also was surprised at the inaccuracy of mammograms.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I really enjoyed Emily's discussion of her battle with cancer and the situations that led up to this diagnosis. I think one of my favorite parts of Emily's story was how she gave complete control to her physician. Something like "This is your job and I am not going to read up on the treatment that you are providing me." Its great that she recognized that it was most beneficial for her to let her doctor to worry about her treatment and for her to just focus on the things she can control.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Listening to Emily's discussion was very interesting for me. I have never really heard first hand someone's experience with breast cancer. In my career I'm sure I will encounter some of these patients, so I think it is important to have an understanding of what these women are going through, past just the medication aspect of their treatment. It was also nice to hear about the specifics that went into her diagnosis, as I will get to that point in my life where I will be doing those same diagnostic tests.

    ReplyDelete