Tuesday, February 2, 2016

1-28-16 Media and Body Image

The American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery reported the Top 5 Cosmetic Surgical Procedures for women in 2012 were:

·         breast augmentation,
·         lipoplasty,
·         abdominoplasty (tummy tuck),
·         blepharoplasty (cosmetic eyelid surgery)
·         rhinoplasty
·         breast lift (moved from 5th to 6th). 

The number of cosmetic procedures for women increased over 250% from 1997. $6.3 billion dollars were spent on surgical cosmetic procedures in 2011 and 79% of the procedures were performed on Caucasians (9% Hispanics, 7% African American, 5% Asians, 1% other).  These cosmetic procedures are not generally covered by insurance unless to treat a medical issue.

(see http://www.surgery.org/media/statistics for more statistics if interested)

Based on the movie America the Beautiful, in what ways do you think the media has influenced the increasing numbers of cosmetic procedures? 

Do you believe individuals reading magazines recognize that the majority of these images are altered by photo shop? 

What are some reasons that Caucasians accounted for the large majority of the cosmetic procedures performed in 2012?

What were your thoughts on a 12 year old girl modeling for women’s clothing lines?  Feel free to add any additional thoughts/questions from what was discussed or presented in class.

Thoughts or comments?

10 comments:

  1. I thought it was crazy how much the people are photoshopped in magazines. I realized they all were but I didn't realize the extent. It's almost as if we are using computer generated people instead of real people to produce the idea of "perfect" body styles.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think the media has influenced the increasing number of cosmetic procedures by making it more accepted as part of our society. I don't think it is only the media's fault for the increasing number of procedures. There is probably an underlying reason as to why people want cosmetic surgery in the first place and the glorification of the "beautiful celebrities" who are photoshopped just feeds into the individual's insecurities. Most people probably know the images are altered by photo shop however when comparing themselves to the pictures they probably do not think about how much the celebrity was actually altered using photo shop. Caucasians are the majority of patients receiving cosmetic surgery perhaps due to the fact that most Caucasians want to be the best or the prettiest. I thought the 12 year old modeling adult clothing was a little outrageous especially when they wanted her size to be even smaller than she already was.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I believe the media has created this idea of what perfection looks like, and people are constantly trying to achieve this image of what a perfect man or woman looks like through cosmetic procedures, whether it be through liposuction or a nose job. The media creates these images through objectification and creating these unreachable body ratios where people don't have a single fat crease or stretch mark or their waists are smaller than their necks.

    I don't think most people realize these images have been altered unless they've consciously made an effort to educate themselves on how the media works. The people I believe are most damaged by these photoshopped images are young teens, who have no idea that these pictures are change to create these body images that are physically unattainable.

    I don't know exactly why Caucasians were responsible for the largest amount of cosmetic surgeries, but my best guess would be that minorities tend to be in a lower socioeconomic class and these surgeries aren't covered by insurance. Caucasians tend to be in a higher economic class, so the are probably the people who can afford to have these outrageously expensive surgeries.

    I think a 12yo modeling is a little too young. I liked how she found a way to turn her height into something that she was being bullied for into something that made her unique and awesome. I just think developmentally she wasn't mature enough to handle the responsibilities and the pressures that come with having a grown up job. Because she was pushed into the adult world so early, so missed out on so many crucial developmental steps for someone her age.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think we're conditioned to believe what we see and not really question it. It's supposed to be an ideal that is fact, rather than fiction. This is how companies make money off of women and what also some feminists have called "distracting" women. If women are busy wearing/buying cosmetics, get engrossed in achieving this ideal, then it is thought they are spending less time on more important things, such as education, politics, self-growth, etc. I definitely find it difficult to remember that what I see in the media is not real...if real women were portrayed in magazines and media, I think a lot more positive body image feelings and talk would occur rather than body shaming. We're all unique and special individuals and that should be celebrated rather than altered/fixed/edited.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I don't believe readers realize that the majority of the photos in magazines are photo-shopped. I personally did not realize that almost every photo in every single magazine is photo-shopped. I had assumed that magazines like Cosmo altered most of their photos, but I hadn't realized that magazines like US weekly also did that. I brought up the beach-body article of US weekly in class, but I still keep thinking back to that and how much media effects women. I know someone that buys that article every year because it makes her feel better to see celebrities with the worst beach-body. There is no way women can compare themselves to the pictures of women in magazines, because the pictures in magazines are completely fake due to alteration from photo-shop.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I don't disagree in thinking that plastic surgery is a big issue with people in society today, I think that it is. However I would be interested in seeing statistics on cosmetic procedures performed. I think that commonly in documentaries or publications like this one that is focusing on the issue of beauty and image issues they use phrases like "Caucasians accounted for the large majority of the cosmetic procedures", to make it seem like a big issue. What they don't talk about are the people who used plastic surgery for health reasons, which is why I would like to see statistics on these procedures. For example badly burned patients getting skin grafts, or fixing a deviated septum for breathing purposes, or even a breast reduction for spine and breathing issues. There are a lot of people having surgeries not for cosmetic reasons but for health reasons as well and their numbers get put into the statistics used in these articles or documentaries, so I think that these stats or broad statements can be skewed somewhat if you aren't taking into consideration people getting cosmetic surgery for other reasons.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I really enjoyed watching "America the Beautiful." It definitely put a lot of things in perspective of how woman are portrayed in media. One of the things that stood out to me was the editor of one of the magazines, I think it was Elle, who was interviewed about the use of extremely photoshopped pictures in the magazine. Immediately, the editors response was "Well, we aren't the only ones." I hope that sometime magazines will begin using more body-positive images of women in their magazines. Since watching that movie, I have been much more cognizant of the images that I see of women in media and advertisements.

    I think that having a modeling career at age 12 is too young. It is a lot of responsibility for a child, especially since her mother was also relying on her income. This put a lot of pressure on her, especially when she was no longer getting booked for shows. I think that it robbed her from the ability to have a normal childhood, and she lost some valuable time that most kids use to grow and develop.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think America the Beautiful is definitely well worth the watch. I think the media pretty heavily influences the number of cosmetic procedures. I think there's so much overexposure to thin, beautiful women that people start to believe that's normal or that they should be able to attain that if they put in the effort or have the procedure. I think a really prime example of what's happening in the media shaping what kinds of cosmetic procedures are performed is butt implants. I couldn't have imagined butt implants being a desired procedure before the Kardashian women were heavily featured in the media.

    I do think a lot of women realize that images in magazines are photoshopped, but I don't really believe that they realize the extent of it. I think it's really hard to read a magazine article about "this diet and exercise routine got such-and-such famous person's beach body back" and fully understand that the photo of that famous person in the article isn't at all an accurate representation of what their body looked like at that photo shoot. I think when you're reading an article like that, you're thinking to yourself, "if I just do these things, that's the body I'll have."

    As for a 12 year old modeling women's clothing lines, I think that poses a problem both for the 12 year old, and for the women to which that line is being marketed. A career like that is a lot of responsibility for such a young girl in an industry that can, no doubt, be emotionally trying for an adult. We saw the emotional roller coaster Gerren went through in the film regarding her sense of body image, and I thought that was really heartbreaking. I also think it's a horrible idea to have her model women's clothing. How are women supposed to feel about their bodies when they're looking at a 12 year old body model those clothes? It's not like they advertised that she's that young, so she's contributing to that unattainable, ideal body that women will beat themselves up for not having.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I thought the America the Beautiful was a great movie to watch. I think it is crazy how our world is turning and how a teenage girl could feel like her career was over before the age of 18. Personally I believe our world in a way has lost sight of true beauty and has become more focused on implants everywhere (butts, boobs, muscles, jaw). I worry for young girls who see all of these airbrushed photos of flawless women and think that this is normal.

    ReplyDelete